Site Meter Scrapropos » Blog Archive » Q&A: Simple vs Creative. How do you know?

Q&A: Simple vs Creative. How do you know?

by Stacy Kocur

QUESTION:
How do you know when simple is better with all the new more creative things out there? - Tonya in Fort Worth

How *do* you know? I’m not even sure how to answer it. Except to say, sometimes the photos and the stories they’re telling just SPEAK to you, if you’ll listen.

What is it that you want to convey? What are the photos telling you? Is the story full of excitement, laughter, energy, noise, action? If so, you can reflect that by using papers and embellishments that are loud, busy, and interactive. Are the photos telling you a story that’s sweet, simple, straight-forward, shy, calm? Evoke those emotions by using colors and embellishments that lean towards those feelings.

For this page, I wanted to convey a feeling of spunkiness, and yet, the colors I needed to work with don’t really say “spunk”. To help liven it up, I chose papers that were complementary, yet not too matchy. Layering, tearing and inking added more personality to the page.

This photo whispered softness and simplicity to me, so I used bare-bones techniques and soft colors:

I’d be lying if I didn’t admit that sometimes, I buy papers and embellishments just because I like them. When this Bohemia line of paper came out last year, I snapped it up. I couldn’t WAIT to find a use for it. I went straight home, pored over my photo files, and found one that worked perfectly after I converted it to sepia tones. I knew I wanted it to be a simple layout, but when I was finished, it seemed to still be missing something. Something small, but something nonetheless. The initialed paper clip embellishment was the perfect answer.

Everyone takes photos that aren’t wonderful, but still need to be included in the family albums. Maybe they’re just standard Christmas photos of everyone opening gifts. Perhaps it’s another series of soccer game pics. Maybe it’s your kid playing dress-up, or trains, but there’s nothing really special about the photos except that they capture the sweetness of childhood. In those instances, don’t be afraid to scrap simply. Not every page has to be a work of art. Here are some of my “just get it scrapped” pages where I didn’t worry so much about the creativity aspect of it:

You know whether to scrap simply or creatively when the photos tell you to. My friend and fellow scrapper Elaine in AL is an artist and does some really creative pages. But even she understands the value of a simple page. Tonight as we were chatting, she said, “I just slapped a page together. Felt good. Just cropped the pictures, tore some borders, slapped ‘em down, journaled. Ahhh.”

I know that feeling. Ahhhhhh. It’s the feeling you get when you’ve completed a page, savored the memory, and enjoyed the process. If you’ve agonized over it too much, you haven’t enjoyed it. If you’ve spent too much money on it, you likely feel guilty somehow. Sometimes, less isn’t necessarily MORE, but it’s enough. As Elaine’s favorite quilting teacher once said, “Sometimes the eye just needs somewhere to rest.” If every one of your pages is crammed with trendy, creative blasts of color and embellishments, there’s no rest.

Let the story be your guide. Let the photos tell you that story.
And in the end, remember my scrap hero Ali Edwards’ famous words: “It is okay.”

Did You Enjoy this Post? Subscribe to Scrapropos. It's Free!

2 Responses to “Q&A: Simple vs Creative. How do you know?”

  1. Tonya Says:

    Never thought you would use my question…but it is one that I struggle with regularly. Everyone wants to use the latest and greatest things and sometimes, I just want to show how beautiful my family is. How much I love every minute with them. How beautiful the sun is shining on my DD’s beautiful face. I don’t want the ink, brads, and fibers to be what is special. This article is perfect!

  2. Karen (ksheffer) Says:

    I love that Share layout. Very simple but well thought out, it seems. It complements without overpowering.

Leave a Reply


About Scrapropos

At (Scr)apropos it’s always the right time for scrapbooking. Here you’ll find inspiration for completing layouts, trying new techniques, and getting your supplies organized. Find out about new products first, see who is hot in the scrapbooking industry, and enter contests for fun prizes. Join (Scr)apropos and celebrate your creativity while preserving your cherished memories.

Scrapropos Author(s)
    » Ann-LuMaye

Crafts & Hobbies Channel Posts

  • Contest Wrap Up: Thank You and Cool Stuff
    I'm pleased to announce that the contest to benefit Toys For Tots is now over. All that's left is getting the winner picks from the official number picker. In the meantime, I'd like to thank [...]
  • Happy New Year
    Let's try to start this new year out with a bang, shall we? You might be scratching your heads and wondering where in the world the Knitting Passion has gone . . . has she lost her mojo? Where in the [...]
  • Custom Figure Corner: Micronauts Figures That Give Nerdgasms
    I like shitty comics. Not all shitty comics, mind you, but I'm the proud owner of many an issues of comics that are rarely seen outside of a quarter bin in a comics shop. The funny thing is that some [...]
  • Contest Update: Now You Don't Have An Excuse
    It's come to my attention recently by a Mr. Poe Ghostal that if you donate for Toys For Tots online you get an email receipt that doesn't give any personal information away (except for your name [...]
  • Come With This Bear if You Want to Live
    In the coming months and weeks you'll be seeing a lot more coverage of Terminator toys here at Toy Bender, because frankly I'm a Terminator freak. One interesting addition to the Terminator in toy [...]
  • Amanda Waller and Some Ranting
    Fans of the Justice League Unlimited series of figures sold exclusively at Target might be pleased to learn that they will have the chance to own an Amanda Waller figure in the future. While she [...]
  • Friday Wrap Up: Post Christmas Edition
    Wow, another Christmas down. Hope it was a good one for you! Item: Oh boy, I forgot how big of a dip in traffic one gets during Christmas and Christmas Eve. It's funny to see almost the [...]
  • 2009 Crafting Plans
    There were so many new projects I wanted to start in November/December but put them off until I was done with Christmas. Now that my Christmas crafting is over, I can start some of these projects [...]
  • Merry Christmas From Toy Bender
    It's that time of the year again! It's Christmas time if you're a God fearing red blooded, meat eating, non-tree hugging American. The last few years of Toy Bender's reign over the toy related [...]
  • Predator Figures from Hot Toys that Aren't Predators!
    Hot Toys has been consistently making some super sweet toys for awhile now and even though I really admire a lot of their products, it took Dutch from Predator to make me want to buy one of their [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • First impressions: "A Father Dreams"
    A few quick thoughts on last night's Brothers and Sisters episode. Tune in during the coming week for a recap, memorable lines, and five questions. • So apparently, in the short period of time [...]
  • Fugitives Spoilers from E!
    In this week’s edition of Spoiler Chat, E! Online’s Kristin Dos Santos gives us a few teasers about what we can expect when Volume 4, “Fugitives” starts up in February.  Nathan [...]
  • Bracing For Lost Season 5, Evangeline Lilly Says Be Patient
    How many days left? Just under two weeks right? How many previews and teasers have you watched? They've released a couple more during the holidays but I personally didn't try to take a peek; I'm [...]
  • Tonight's Raw Matches: IC Title and More
    The following is posted on WWE.com: -It's the very first edition of Monday Night Raw in 2009 and CM Punk has the golden opportunity against a familiar rival. The Sraightedge Superstar faces [...]
  • The Saga of Andrew Jones
    Wow, how far Andrew Jones has fallen. In the past few years, he's gone from being a premier slugger who created dazzling plays to a shell of his old self. The Los Angeles Dodgers have agreed to [...]
  • I Miss My Kitties
    I really miss my Sherbert, a long haired orange cat with many Maine Coon tendencies and features. He escaped one night by opening the screen door (he was too smart for his own good) and we think he [...]
  • Tony Collapsed After Losing to Eagles
    Dallas Cowboy’s quarterback and Jessica Simpson’s beau, Tony Romo collapsed in the shower after a game (which they lost) against the Philadelphia Eagles. His three turnovers in the game [...]
  • John Pelphrey press conference - Texas
    The Razorbacks and No. 7-ranked Longhorns tip off at 8:05 p.m. Tuesday from Bud Walton Arena. [...]
  • Jeff Moorad To Buy Padres
    Jeff Moorad resigned as Arizona Diamondbacks chief executive officer and says he has reached an agreement in principle to buy the San Diego Padres. Moorad said he heads a "small but significant" [...]
  • A small update to the OneNote Table of Contents Powertoy
    John Guin has an update for OneNote:Over the in the OneNote Discussion Group, Mike made this request for a change to the Table of Contents Powertoy: "I have downloaded and used the TOC power toy. [...]