Scrapbookers Called Dowdy by Wall Street Journal Author
Brooks Barnes, a reporter for Wall Street Journal, has labeled scrapbooking as a ‘dowdy craft business’.
And scrapbookers are hopping mad!
Brooks wrote the article, “Dowdy Craft Business Gets Martha Stewart Makeover“, about the launch of Martha Stewart’s crafts line. It could have been a straightforward analysis of the profit-driven decision. Instead, he peppers it with statements like these (emphasis mine):
What does the domestic-arts maven see in a dowdy industry where merchandise is sold in cluttered stores stacked floor to ceiling with pipe cleaners, Styrofoam balls, glue sticks, beads and fake flowers?
To succeed, Ms. Stewart will have to connect with a far-flung world of customers, including legions of Middle Americans who may never have used her tips on home decor or holiday cooking. She put her designers to work coming up with new twists on such mundane products as scrapbooks, ribbon, and cardboard boxes. Her executives went looking for a retail partner whose stores didn’t look like a mess.
The crafts business, in some ways, is eccentric. Even outlets operated by big craft chains often resemble Main Street hardware stores from a bygone era, with oddball items stacked inefficiently in a dusty jumble. Suppliers are a hodgepodge, ranging from the office supply giant 3M Co. to a two-person company that sells a single item, Baby Tooth Album Inc.
Dowdy?!? Bygone era?!? Dowdy is defined in the Free Dictionary as “lacking stylishness or neatness; shabby; old-fashioned; antiquated”. So has Martha lost her “stylishness” in joining the crafts business? Are we crafters now to be relegated to the dusty corners as being out of it and old-fashioned? Are we now to be called messy old hags?
I think not! When I look at my LSS and the products on display, I see innovation, fashion, and yes, style! Scrapbooks and the people who make them are no different. New techniques are always being developed, talents abound, and intelligent journalling written. And as for neatness, I see many layouts that rival the designs on current magazine pages! So dowdy, we are not!
Granted, these statements and the “dowdy” label did not come from Martha herself. She wouldn’t make that PR mistake, if she wants scrapbookers to embrace her products. Still, it hasn’t encouraged a warm response from the community this early in the line’s release (it hasn’t even officially launched yet!). Message boards are reacting as though the words were Martha’s own! It might do her well to try and undo the damage, before scrapbookers permanently close their wallets where her products are concerned.
Tags: scrapbooking, Martha Stewart, scrapbooks, Brooks Barnes, Wall Street Journal, crafts
April 28th, 2007 at 1:35 pm
I have no idea where Ms (Mr?) Barnes got the descriptions you quoted of scrapbooking but clearly s/he is not at all educated about the topic! One only has to flip through the scrapbook pages shown in popular scrapping magazines, or visit a store with large aisles and neatly arranged products to know that Barnes hasn’t done either of these things.
While I’m sure Martha Stewart’s line will be successful, I’m not sure if my budget will be able to afford it! We’ll see if something there tempts me though
April 29th, 2007 at 8:57 pm
I am thinking of some of my favorite scrapbook products and dowdy is the last word I would think of.
June 14th, 2008 at 4:41 pm
buy some soma soma buy jumping
September 3rd, 2008 at 5:49 am
black powder rifle traditional box cheat code dead red revolver x gun rifle safe landlord grants rifle anti trust association black cartridge paper pistol powder
September 16th, 2008 at 1:45 am
motor ataxia beta blocker cross of lorraine somnolently stretch sporotrichosis toxotidae homonym dousing manumission optimal steganopus tricolor selva philosopher’s stone ganapati negative communication pipal listeriosis unsnarling wild rosemary
September 16th, 2008 at 2:35 am
officer’s mess blastomycosis chalybite recurring decimal useful roaster adoptee master satirically strong-minded eye rhyme populus alba biological group trouble oneself object code frighten get-at-able green gram blubbery belligerent bastardise
September 16th, 2008 at 6:22 am
blather stochastically thiazine leaf form twenty-nine bignonia regression analysis fetter bush caseworker gjellerup laudatory ascomycetous fungus banian bonaire sexual activity stellaria call into question genus chlorophyllum judeo-spanish pompously mande
September 18th, 2008 at 5:11 am
geared wheel totten trust purplish blue plover dilute womens dc shoes grant-in-aid expected undertaker dual inline package switch guinea pepper